Rock star John Mellencamp is shown in Bloomington, Ind., in this Aug. 31, 2000, photo. Timothy O. Eldredge, an Indianapolis home builder accused of double-billing Mellencamp, has agreed to plead guilty to theft and pay more than $98,000 restitution, according to the Marion County Prosecutor's office. In exchange for his guilty plea, prosecutors agreed to dismiss more serious charges, according to documents the prosecutor's office released Monday, July 23, 2001 in Indianapolis. (AP Photo/Bloomington Herald Times, Chris Howell)